As a comparison of both content and the corresponding ways in which both Davis and McNeil fit within the historical paradigm ¡°Liberalism versus Political Economy¡± this paper will examine both the viewpoint from which each author writes from, and also build a critical analysis using a common theme from both ¡°something new under the sun,¡± and ¡°Let Victorian Holocausts.¡± The common theme from each book to be examined will be ¡°Water¡± and how water has …showed first 75 words of 1402 total…

…showed last 75 words of 1402 total…utter separation between Davis and McNeil. In summary, Davis writes of a compelling story about exploitation of India by the Imperialistic British Crown. He tells of market fixing, drought, famine, class struggle, water depletion, and social struggle, all from the eyes of a political economist. The contrast within the paradigm is so great when comparing these two writers, that the second you look at Davis¡¯s story through McNeil¡¯s eyes, it did not happen.